College saving: MESP or MET?

Residents in Michigan have two options in terms of college education savings, if desired to obtain tax benefits from state income tax.

Residents in Michigan have two options in terms of college education savings, if desired to obtain tax benefits from state income tax.

  • MESP: Michigan Education Savings Plan or Michigan state version of 529 college savings plan. It offers a list of investment mutual fund portfolio that the account owner can choose based on risk tolerance, child’s age, etc. MESP allows account owner to hire a financial advisor to manage the account and choose appropriate mutual fund portfolio for them.
  • MET: A prepaid tuition plan that the credits purchased can be used for future higher education tuition, books, fees etc. if the child chose to attend a Michigan public college. The assumed tuition increase is about 6% a year.
  • Questions frequently asked:
    • Tax benefit: maximum state tax free contribution of $10,000 per family per year. This is about $400 state tax savings if contributed the full amount
    • What if my kid doesn’t attend Michigan public college:
      • MET: redeem at average Michigan public college tuition cost of the school year.
      • MESP: The money in account can be used at any college, any state, undergraduate or graduate, public or private, in the US.
    • What if my kid doesn’t attend go to college:
      • MET: redeem at average Michigan public college tuition cost of the school year.
      • MESP:
        • Non-qualified withdraw: redeem cash can be used for anything with penalty (worst choice).
        • Transfer the beneficiary to another person of the family
        • Rollover to Roth IRA
        • Other options
    • Should I buy MET or MESP:
      • MET:
        • About 6% assumed return to defend college tuition increase
        • Best deal for the family if attend expensive public college in Michigan like UM-Ann Arbor or MSU
        • Not as good deal if kid attends cheap tuition public Michigan college
      • MESP:
        • Full amount in account can be used in any college
        • Much higher investment return if invested properly

Tags: